Building The Ultimate NFL QB With Scott Mitchell

Jun 19, 2019, 9:15 AM | Updated: 10:23 am

John Elway #7, Quarterback for the Denver Broncos calls the play on the line of scrimmage during th...

John Elway #7, Quarterback for the Denver Broncos calls the play on the line of scrimmage during the American Football Conference West game against the Kansas City Chiefs on 6 December 1998 at the Mile High Stadium, Denver, Colorado, United States. The Broncos won the game 35 - 31. (Photo by Stephen Dunn/Getty Images)

(Photo by Stephen Dunn/Getty Images)

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah – Think of the greatest quarterbacks you know. Now take them apart and piece together the best parts of each one to create a super quarterback.

On Helmets Off Podcast, Scott Mitchell, a former NFL quarterback himself, built what he calls “the perfect quarterback.”

Mitchell broke it down in four parts – feet, arm, head and most importantly heart.

The Feet

Some of the names that initially came to Mitchell’s mind when thinking about quick, athletic quarterbacks included Steve Young, Cam Newton and Michael Vick.

“Steve young re-wrote athleticism as it relates to quarterbacks,” Mitchell complimented the former BYU superstar.

He couldn’t choose just one. Mitchell cheated at his own game and picked two quarterbacks’ feet, one for each leg. One leg is the runner and one is the footwork artist.

“In all reality, to have the ultimate quarterback, you have to have both of those things,” said Mitchell.

From a pure athletic and speed perspective, according to Mitchell, there was no one better than Michael Vick. He described Vick’s ability to run the football as “freakish”

He chose Joe Montanna’s footwork on the other leg. Mitchell described Montanna’s movement in the pocket as “graceful precision”. Every move he made was with a purpose, according to Mitchell.

The Arm

Quarterbacks have two arms so Mitchell chose two for this category as well. One arm is sheer strength and the other is accuracy. Some quarterbacks have cannon arms but lack the accuracy and that leads to interceptions, Mitchell brought up.

Randall Cunningham, Brett Favre and John Elway all got thrown in the arm strength discussion. In the end, Mitchell picked Elway’s “cannon arm.”

Elway’s arm is so legendary there is a rumor of the “Elway Cross”. If one of his passes hit a receiver in an unprotected area it would leave a cross mark from the stitching of the ball.

As for accuracy, Dan Marino takes the other arm.

“His accuracy and precision were spectacular,” described Mitchell.

Mitchell had a front row seat to watch Marino’s precision and the work that went into creating it, as Marino’s backup with the Miami Dolphins.

The Head

Mitchell said there are two sides of the brain, right and left, so gets to choose two here also. One is what he called football IQ or knowledge of the game. The other is leadership and the ability to handle and react to pressure.

He chose Peyton Manning for his knowledge of the game because he changed the level of preparation and understanding required for quarterbacks going into every game, according to Mitchell.

“With his level of preparation, I believe he took football to a whole new level,” Mitchell said on the podcast, “No one prepared harder.”

The other side is Roger Staubach. He was captain of the field and lovingly known as “Captain America” to Dallas Cowboys fans.

“Roger Staubach is like George Washington…he is the leader you want on your team,” Mitchell described.

The Heart

Some players just have the pursuit of excellence, the will to win and the ability to perform in clutch situations. That is the heart.

There is no other heart Mitchell would rather have than Tom Brady.

“I can’t even think of another player who fits this category other than Brady,” said Mitchell, “He has the heart of a lion and his rings prove it.”


MORE:


“This quarterback would be unbeatable, you couldn’t touch it,” he closed.

Mitchell wants to know how you would build your super quarterback. Find Helmets Off and Facebook and let him know.

If you enjoyed this episode, subscribe to Helmets Off wherever you get podcasts or on the KSL Sports app.

Listen to the full episode below.

NFL

Jordan Love #10 of the Green Bay Packers vs. Panthers 2026...

Brian Preece

Packers ride Jordan Love’s arm to Thursday night win over Devin Lloyd’s Panthers

Jordan Love threw for 288 yards and three touchdowns as the Green Bay Packers held off the Carolina Panthers for a 27-19 win on Thursday Night Football.

1 day ago

Jaylen Warren #30 of the Pittsburgh Steelers Week 5...

Brian Preece

Locals in the NFL: ‘He’s hot’, Jaylen Warren earns featured role in Steelers offense

Former East High standout Jaylen Warren is climbing the NFL rushing and scrimmage-yard rankings after a breakout stretch with the Steelers.

17 days ago

Caleb Lomu #74 of the New England Patriots Week 5...

Brian Preece

Locals in the NFL: Patriots could turn to rookie Caleb Lomu at left tackle against Jets

With Will Campbell expected to miss time, first-round pick Caleb Lomu may be asked to protect Drake Maye against the Jets’ pass rush.

17 days ago

Puka Nacua #12 of the Los Angeles Rams Week 5...

Brian Preece

Locals in the NFL: Puka Nacua’s career day ends in heartbreak as Rams fall to Bills in OT

Puka Nacua caught a career-high 17 passes for 138 yards and a touchdown, but the Los Angeles Rams fell to the Buffalo Bills 37-34 in overtime.

18 days ago

Jordan Love #10 of the Green Bay Packers Week 5, 2026...

Brian Preece

Locals in the NFL: Packers ride Jordan Love’s big game to 31-7 win over Bears

Jordan Love completed 25 of 31 passes for 367 yards and two touchdowns, leading the Packers to a 31-7 win over the Bears.

19 days ago

Tyler Huntley #5 of the Baltimore Ravens NFL...

Brian Preece

Locals in the NFL: Tyler Huntley expected to make first start as injuries impact locals

Tyler Huntley prepares for a Ravens start as several Utah NFL locals work toward returns. Check the latest Week 5 injury updates.

21 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Photos provided by families of featured athletes...

KSL Sports

Northern Utah Player of the Week – Week 7 – Carson Murphy

The John Watson Northern Utah High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school football player in Northern Utah.

Photos provided by family of featured athletes...

Salt Lake County High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 13 – Stacia Peoples & Gavin Lowe

The Hercules Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Salt Lake County.

...

Northern Utah High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 13 – Rachel McBride & Lincoln Smith

The John Watson Northern Utah High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Northern Utah.

Photos provided by featured athletes...

Utah County High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 13 – Janiece Sikander & Brody Thompson

The Mr. Mac Utah County High School Player of the Week is awarded each week to the top prep boy's and girl's basketball players in Utah County.

Photos provided by featured athletes...

Salt Lake County High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 12 – Evy Roberts & Krew Eckman

The Hercules Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Salt Lake County.

Photos provided by family of featured athletes...

Northern Utah High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 12 – Fabiana Lopez, Madden Johnsen & Bracken Saunders

The John Watson Northern Utah High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Northern Utah.

Building The Ultimate NFL QB With Scott Mitchell