BYU COUGARS

Bizarre BYU Season Capped Off With Loss In Wild Hawaii Bowl

Dec 24, 2019, 11:13 PM | Updated: 11:18 pm

Bizarre is the one word that comes to mind when summarizing the 2019 BYU Football season. On Christmas Eve, BYU concluded their season with a loss to the Hawaii Rainbow Warriors, 38-34.

With the loss, BYU ends the season with a 7-6 record and like many of the losses this season, the Cougars will look back on the Hawaii Bowl and nitpick the missed opportunities.

Those missed opportunities are magnified in the second half. Hawaii’s offense jumped on BYU early getting out to a 14-0 and held a 31-24 lead at the halftime break. Rainbow Warrior quarterback Cole McDonald passed for 331 yards in the first half. But BYU kept battling and didn’t give up.

BYU’s defense made adjustments and held Hawaii to (-4) total yards in the third quarter. But the Cougar offense only scored seven points in that quarter. One of BYU’s offensive drives started on the Hawaii 34 yard-line and the Cougars came up scoreless after quarterback Zach Wilson had a controversial fumble at the goal line.

BYU couldn’t finish the job in the fourth quarter

In the fourth quarter, BYU opened the final frame with a Jake Oldroyd 20-yard field goal that gave BYU its first lead of the game at 34-31 with 14:37 remaining. Then Hawaii’s offense came back to life, but the Warriors continued to leave the door open for BYU to put the game away.

BYU had their own missed field goal by Oldroyd that looked at first glance to go through the uprights, but officials said it was no good.

Two possessions later BYU still had their 34-31 lead with 4:07 remaining in the game. The Cougars had the opportunity to close it out and give Kalani Sitake his third consecutive bowl win in as many appearances, but they couldn’t get it done. On 3rd & 2, Wilson threw a pass intended for wide receiver Micah Simon that went into the Aloha Stadium turf. BYU was forced to punt, giving the ball and all the momentum back to Hawaii.

As he did so many times earlier in the game, McDonald took a shot downfield and found a wide-open Nick Mardner for a gain of 38 yards. One play later, McDonald found Mardner again for a 24-yard touchdown that put the Rainbow Warriors up for good.

BYU’s final drive showed promise as they moved into Rainbow Warrior territory but it concluded with a Wilson pass that was intercepted by Hawaii’s Khoury Bethley.

Aloha means a disappointing loss for the Cougars.

Mitch Harper is a BYU Insider for sports.ksl.com and host of the Cougar Tracks Podcast (SUBSCRIBE) and Cougar Sports Saturday (Saturday from 12-3 pm) on KSL Newsradio. Follow him on Twitter: @Mitch_Harper.

  • BYU Cougars Scoreboard

  • BYU Cougars Team Leaders

  • BYU Cougars Standings

BYU Cougars

BYU's Afton Perry scored two goals as the Cougars topped Idaho State 5-1 in an exhibition match, Sa...

Sean Walker

Why a 5-1 exhibition win over Idaho State meant so much to BYU’s Afton Perry

Afton Perry recorded a brace in the Cougars' 5-1 exhibition win over Idaho State, a significant move by the sophomore from Saratoga Springs expected to take a big step forward with the BYU women's soccer team.

10 hours ago

BYU football, Kalani Sitake, Fall Camp, 2026, day one...

Mitch Harper

What caught my attention on Day 1 of BYU football fall camp

Notes and observations from day one at Camp Kalani.

4 days ago

BYU football roster, fall camp, 2026 season, Bear Bachmeier...

Mitch Harper

2026 BYU Cougars football roster to open fall camp

A fresh new roster as BYU kicks off fall camp.

5 days ago

BYU Football, Journee Tonga, Fall Camp...

Mitch Harper

BYU football adds three-star running back for 2026 season

BYU adds another ball carrier to the program.

5 days ago

Top 25, BYU, Utah, Preseason Coaches Poll...

Mitch Harper

BYU, Utah appear in preseason Coaches Poll Top 25

Nationally ranked teams in the state to kick off 2026.

6 days ago

BYU Football, Starting Lineup Projection, Bruce Mitchell...

Sean Walker

BYU football’s Mitchell, Tanuvasa named to Outland Trophy watch list

BYU football center Bruce Mitchell and defensive tackle Keanu Tanuvasa were among the 68 players named to the 2026 Outland Trophy watch list, given annually to the nation's top interior lineman.

6 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Photos provided by family of featured athletes...

Salt Lake County High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 13 – Stacia Peoples & Gavin Lowe

The Hercules Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Salt Lake County.

...

Northern Utah High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 13 – Rachel McBride & Lincoln Smith

The John Watson Northern Utah High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Northern Utah.

Photos provided by featured athletes...

Utah County High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 13 – Janiece Sikander & Brody Thompson

The Mr. Mac Utah County High School Player of the Week is awarded each week to the top prep boy's and girl's basketball players in Utah County.

Photos provided by featured athletes...

Salt Lake County High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 12 – Evy Roberts & Krew Eckman

The Hercules Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Salt Lake County.

Photos provided by family of featured athletes...

Northern Utah High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 12 – Fabiana Lopez, Madden Johnsen & Bracken Saunders

The John Watson Northern Utah High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school basketball players in Northern Utah.

Photos provided by featured athletes...

Utah County High School Basketball Players of the Week – Week 12 – Leah Bailey & Lucas Castagnetto

The Mr. Mac Utah County High School Player of the Week is awarded each week to the top prep boy's and girl's basketball players in Utah County.

Bizarre BYU Season Capped Off With Loss In Wild Hawaii Bowl